“Why should a producing asset trade at 80% of NAV, while a development asset trades at just 10% or 20%? It’s a huge arbitrage opportunity,”
Jon Goodman, Dundee Corporation
5 Key Takeaways
- M&A in Gold and Copper Is Inevitable: As established producers face declining production profiles, mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are crucial to sustain growth.
- Strategic Deals Are Driving Industry Transformation: Companies like G Mining and Reunion Gold exemplify successful M&A transactions, focusing on growth through quality assets.
- Risks of Single-Asset Companies Are Increasing: One-mine companies remain highly vulnerable, with the need to diversify through acquisitions or partnerships more critical than ever.
- Valuation Gaps Persist: Despite solid exploration results, junior miners frequently trade far below their net asset value (NAV), frustrating investors and companies alike.
- Gold Stocks Lag Behind Gold Prices: While gold prices are on the rise, gold-producing stocks have failed to match this performance, indicating broader market sentiment issues.
—
Who is Jon Goodman?
Dundee Corporation, an asset management firm led by Jon Goodman, focuses on investments in junior mining companies, particularly in the gold and copper sectors. With a long-standing reputation for successful investments in mining, Dundee’s model emphasizes two potential outcomes for juniors: build a mine or sell the asset.
The firm’s investment in Reunion Gold, later acquired by G Mining, is a prime example of a successful M&A transaction. Dundee also invests in juniors like Magna Mining and Saturn Metals, positioning itself as a key player in the ever-evolving mining space. With a focus on strategic acquisitions and detailed due diligence, Dundee continues to leverage its deep industry expertise to drive value creation across its portfolio.
—
The Rise of M&A in Gold and Copper
Jon Goodman, a seasoned leader in the mining investment space, remains unequivocal about the inevitable rise of M&A in the gold and copper sectors. In an industry where depletion of high- grade ore is a constant threat, companies must either expand their operations or acquire new assets. Goodman describes this as a “self-fulfilling prophecy,” where declining production profiles force producers onto a treadmill of constant asset acquisition.
“The only way for them to get their production profile from declining is by building new mines or through M&A,” Goodman explains. He highlights that while mine development is an option, acquiring assets—whether producing mines or development-stage projects—remains the most efficient method for companies to maintain growth.
The phenomenon Goodman describes is well-documented in mining. As companies exhaust their best ore, they must secure new resources to maintain profitability. M&A becomes not just an opportunity but a necessity for long-term survival. With large producers constantly seeking new projects to replace depleting resources, the junior mining space stands to benefit, positioning itself as a prime source of attractive assets ripe for acquisition.
—
G Mining and Reunion Gold: A Strategic Case Study
One of Dundee’s key recent successes was its involvement in the acquisition of Reunion Gold by G Mining. As the largest shareholder in Reunion, Dundee was instrumental in the deal’s execution, which Goodman views as a well-structured transaction. Reunion’s shareholders received G Mining shares, a company with a promising development project in Brazil and long-term growth potential.
“We were very involved in the G Mining takeover of Reunion. It was a well-designed deal because the paper you’re getting is expected to trade at a valuation you’re comfortable holding long-term,” says Goodman. He notes that while Dundee sold part of its G Mining stake due to portfolio management needs, the company remains optimistic about G Mining’s future as it builds its mine in Brazil.
The success of this deal underscores the importance of structuring M&A transactions carefully. For investors in junior companies like Reunion, the key is to receive shares in an acquiring company with strong growth potential. Dundee’s decision to maintain a substantial position in G Mining reflects its belief in the long-term value of the assets acquired, particularly as G Mining’s projects in Brazil and Guyana continue to develop.
—
One-Mine Companies: High Risk, High Vulnerability
Goodman is notably critical of one-mine companies, emphasizing their inherent vulnerability. A single asset leaves a company exposed to a range of risks, from operational failures to geopolitical instability. While such companies can still be attractive investments, the need for diversification is paramount.
“A one-mine company… is vulnerable. You’re out of business if a coup happens, or a fire breaks out at the mine,” Goodman says, highlighting the high stakes of operating without asset diversification. While single-mine operations can generate substantial returns in stable environments, the potential for sudden disruption looms large.
For junior mining companies, having only one asset can be a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it simplifies management and focuses resources. On the other, it leaves the company entirely dependent on the success of that asset, exposing shareholders to significant risk. Goodman’s warning reflects a broader trend in the industry: investors and companies alike must recognize that single-asset strategies may no longer be viable in today’s uncertain geopolitical and economic environment.
—
Valuation Gaps: Why Juniors Struggle to Attract Value
A recurring theme in Goodman’s analysis is the persistent gap between the value of junior mining companies’ assets and their stock market valuations. Despite positive exploration results and promising resources, many juniors trade at a fraction of their net asset value (NAV). Goodman views this disconnect as a function of broader market trends, where investors increasingly favor low-risk instruments like exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and royalties over direct investments in junior mining stocks.
“Why should a producing asset trade at 80% of NAV, while a development asset trades at just 10% or 20%? It’s a huge arbitrage opportunity,” Goodman asserts, pointing to the undervaluation of development-stage assets as a major issue in the mining sector.
Analysis:
This valuation gap is a significant challenge for junior miners. While established producers enjoy higher valuations, juniors often struggle to gain investor confidence, even when their assets show promise. The rise of ETFs and royalty companies has further complicated matters, as these instruments are seen as safer, more predictable investments. For juniors to close the gap, they will need to improve investor communication and demonstrate that they can deliver on the long-term potential of their assets.
—
Gold Stocks vs. Gold Price: A Puzzling Disconnect
Despite gold prices reaching near-record highs, Goodman notes that gold-producing stocks have failed to follow suit. This disconnect, he argues, is partly due to the growing appeal of royalty companies, which offer exposure to gold without the operational risks associated with mining. However, Goodman remains bullish on gold stocks, noting that rising gold prices should, in theory, lead to significant gains for producers.
“There’s no reason the price of gold should outperform a gold-producing stock. Yet, we’ve seen gold stocks lag behind,” he says, expressing frustration at the market’s preference for royalty companies and ETFs over direct equity investment in miners.
The underperformance of gold stocks relative to the price of gold is a reflection of broader market sentiment. Investors are wary of the risks associated with mining—operational failures, cost overruns, and geopolitical instability—making royalty companies and ETFs more attractive. However, Goodman’s point is well taken: as margins improve with rising gold prices, there is likely to be a catch-up effect where gold stocks finally begin to outperform. For long-term investors, the current disparity may represent a buying opportunity.
—
Conclusion: The Future of M&A in Gold and Copper
As M&A activity accelerates in the gold and copper sectors, junior mining companies will continue to play a pivotal role in feeding the appetite of larger producers. For companies like Dundee, the strategy is clear: identify promising assets, work with management teams to enhance project value, and prepare for either a sale or a transition into production.
The valuation gaps that frustrate junior miners are not insurmountable. With rising gold prices, there is a strong argument that gold-producing stocks are due for a re-rating, and those juniors with strong assets and management teams will be well-positioned to capitalize on this shift.
However, risks remain. One-mine companies will need to diversify or face increasing vulnerability, while the broader market’s preference for low-risk instruments like ETFs and royalties continues to siphon off investor interest in mining equities. For those willing to navigate these challenges, the potential rewards are significant.
Dundee, with its combination of deep technical expertise and strategic vision, is poised to continue finding value in a sector that is often overlooked by the broader market. As M&A heats up, Goodman’s approach of investing in juniors before the market recognizes their true value may well pay off handsomely in the years to come.
Jon Goodman Interview
This is a very brief summary of what was a lengthy interview. Don’t rely on this summary. Watch the full interview which is linked above.
Please note that this guest has not paid for the creation of this content. The Resource Talks interview rules are simple.
The companies, albeit paying or non-paying, get no questions upfront, no questions off the table, and no editing rights.
The information provided herein is general & impersonal in nature and meant for entertainment purposes only. The reader acknowledges and agrees that the information does not constitute a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security or instrument or to participate in any trading strategy. The author is not a licensed investment advisor. He is just another talking head on the internet. He might own shares of companies mentioned in this publication. Always assume he doesn’t know much more than a potato does. The mining & exploration space is among the riskiest sectors to invest in. The risk of anything mentioned in this publication is 100% loss of capital. If you don’t read the official documents provided by the company on http://www.SedarPlus.ca, you will lose all of your money.
